AN ARTISANALLY CURATED TOUR OF SHEFFIELD PUBLIC HOUSES

March 2026. Sheffield.

It was two-thirty on our “cultural Sunday” and we still hadn’t taken our Chicago guests (a bit wary of an extended pub crawl, perhaps), in a pub ! Apart from the breakfast pint in Spoons.

Five and a half hours later we’d rather remedied that omission, and I think Meighan and Dave had worked out what the city is all apart.

But where to start ? Meighan made the decision by heading in the Brown Bear, just as I shouted “No pho...”.

I don’t think Meighan quite appreciated the severity of the offence she was about to commit,

but our American guests did appreciate the gorgeousness of this rather unsung Sam Smiths city centre gem. And the OBB was as good as I’ve had it here, a chewy 3.5.

For complete contrast, Mrs RM then insisted we pop in the Old Shoe for a bit of modernity.

So modern, that’s the first Haircut 100 album they’ve brought for Vinyl Afternoon. Proper hipster.

Modern beer range, Two by Two Porter for Dave, hazy Beak for me.

A toddler plays with toy animals, we pick up posh pizza from next door, it’s a naice place, though Meighan is surprised when I say this is the “classy” place in town. Perhaps the Fargate looks smarter, but Old Shoe is where you get the groups of ladies drink £9 glasses of wine and eat £5 French crisps.

It’s also a place where, freed from Sir Humphrey’s rules, we can finally answer a question about the origin of the fork.

Time to head into Kelham, but I find I can’t quite get past a bustling Shakespeare, and this turns out to be the star turn as the Shakey is hosting a tattoo festival.

It’s possible Mrs RM got that Tenpole Tudor design as a tattoo, but you’ll never find out.

We started with halves (boo !) of Attic Pale, and then shared a third of Amity’s Imperial Stout.

What a pub this is when it’s busy.

Our fourth pub was a little too busy.

I felt obliged to take Dave in Sheffield’s top pub, but sadly a lack of teamwork meant we missed the last two tables in the bar and were consigned to the conservatory, which despite the Hieronymus Bosch is very second best.

Unlike Blue Bee’s American Five Hop, which was perfect (NBSS 5).

You’re drinking condition now” I say to Dave, who recognises a zealot and nods sagely.

And then home, though I take Dave via the view from the top of Blake Hill, which is as good as Sheffield gets.

Except that the Blind Monkey looks to good to miss,

and inside on Acoustic Night we get some top cask and a bloke with a Chris Stapleton T-shirt entertaining us royally for an hour.

Honestly, one of the best days we’ve had in Sheffield since that day the lawn mower broke.

10 thoughts on “AN ARTISANALLY CURATED TOUR OF SHEFFIELD PUBLIC HOUSES

  1. What a great selection of pubs. Sam Smith’s pubs in general are what Americans think of as traditional English pubs. And it has nothing to do with the beer.

    Liked by 1 person

      1. When I went to Spezial in Bamberg, I got chatting to an American family who were visiting the area as their grandfather had been stationed there in the US Army. There was a table of old blokes playing cards on the other side of the room who the teenagers were so obviously fascinated by that eventually they invited them over to watch the game close up.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. I’m glad you found the Amercian Five Hop in such great condition. I’ve found the recent iteration (I think it’s #86) a little underwhelming – too sweet, and lacking a bitter finish – but maybe it’s more to your taste. (I know we’re not meant to allow taste to affect our scores for condition, but it’s hard to leave it out altogether.)

    My beer scores in the Kelham Island Tavern this year have averaged NBSS 3.75, slightly down on last year’s 3.82.

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Until my Sheffield cultural emersion, I’m not sure I knew what good beer actually tasted like! Just wishing I could post my illegal photo here because it’s a good one.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a reply to sheffieldhatter Cancel reply